The S&P rose 0.46% to 7,666.60. The Dow gained 295 points to 53,061.95. The Nasdaq added 0.45% to 26,217.83. The three-day losing streak snapped. And almost none of it was real. Nine of eleven sectors closed red. The rally came from two stocks: Dell surged 13.7% after crushing AI server expectations and raising its full-year revenue target by $25 billion. Nvidia gained 3.2%. Together they did virtually all of the S&P's work. The rest of the market continued falling — Credo Technology collapsed 18.4%, MongoDB fell 10.5%, PG&E dropped another 9.1%, Palo Alto Networks lost 8.4% despite beating estimates, CrowdStrike fell 4.5%. NY Fed President Williams told CNBC there are "no clear signs right now" that a September rate hike is needed. ADP showed the private sector added just 38,000 jobs in August — below the 47,000 expected. The 10-year yield hit 4.81%, its highest since November 2023, before easing slightly. Oil held near $95 Brent but pulled back from session highs. Broadcom and Snowflake report after the close tonight. The indexes say recovery. The internals say something else.
Narrow rally, mega-cap driven. The S&P rose 0.46% to 7,666.60 — snapping a three-day losing streak. The Dow gained 295 points, or 0.56%, to 53,061.95, boosted by Nvidia and Johnson & Johnson. The Nasdaq added 0.45% to 26,217.83. Energy was the only sector to gain meaningfully, rising 1.8% on oil's continued strength. Tech eked out a 0.2% gain — carried entirely by Dell and Nvidia while Palo Alto, CrowdStrike, and MongoDB cratered. Nine of eleven sectors closed red. Communication services was the worst at minus 1.5%. The headline said "stocks rally." The breadth said "two stocks rally."
| The Numbers I Circled | At the close, September 2 · Day change |
|
| S&P 500 | 7,666.60 | +0.46% |
| Dow | 53,061.95 | +0.56% |
| Nasdaq | 26,217.83 | +0.45% |
| S&P 500 Sectors | Day change |
|
| Energy | | +1.8% |
| Info. Technology | | +0.2% |
| Consumer Staples | | −0.3% |
| Health Care | | −0.4% |
| Financials | | −0.5% |
| Industrials | | −0.7% |
| Consumer Disc. | | −0.8% |
| Materials | | −0.8% |
| Utilities | | −0.9% |
| Real Estate | | −0.9% |
| Comm. Services | | −1.5% |
| | Notable Gainers | Day change |
|
| |
| |
| |
| |
| |
Dell was the day's main event. The company reported Tuesday night after the close and crushed expectations across the board: AI server revenue surged, data center equipment beat, and margins expanded. Management raised the full-year revenue target by $25 billion to $192 billion and nearly doubled its AI server revenue forecast to $74 billion. The stock surged 13.7% to $482 — the best performer in the S&P 500 by a wide margin. Dell is now the second-strongest confirmation, after Nvidia, that AI infrastructure spending is accelerating despite everything else weakening. Nvidia gained 3.2% to $224.35 on reports it's in advanced talks to acquire Hugging Face for $14 billion.
The cybersecurity and software complex was the mirror image. Palo Alto Networks fell 8.4% to $331.55 despite beating fourth-quarter estimates. Credo Technology collapsed 18.4%. MongoDB dropped 10.5%. CrowdStrike fell 4.5% to $205.34. Fortinet lost 4.5%. Datadog dropped 4.7%. These companies all beat earnings. Every one of them fell. The market is repricing high-multiple software stocks in a rising-yield environment. When the 10-year yield touches 4.81%, the discount rate goes up and the present value of future earnings goes down — and the stocks that trade at the highest multiples get hit hardest. PG&E continued its slide, falling another 9.1% to $12.78 — down nearly 30% since California lawmakers blocked the wildfire liability bill on Monday.
Williams' comment was the macro catalyst. The New York Fed President told CNBC there are "no clear signs right now" that a September rate hike would be needed, and that the yield surge "reflects a strong economy, not market dysfunction." That's a direct pushback on the hawk narrative from Hammack and Schmid. ADP showed the private sector added just 38,000 jobs in August — below the 47,000 consensus and the weakest reading in months. Manufacturing shed 17,000 jobs. The combination — a dovish Fed voice and a soft labor reading — gave the market the excuse to bounce.
What The Market Is Pricing In
When an index rises 0.46% but nine of eleven sectors decline, the market is telling you the rally has no breadth. The S&P 500 is cap-weighted — Nvidia alone moved it 0.38%. Add Dell's 13.7% surge and you've accounted for nearly the entire gain. The average stock fell. The indexes rose. Traders call this breadth deterioration: the gap between what the headline number says and what the typical stock is doing. It's a warning sign. A rally with narrow breadth can continue for a while — it did in early 2024 when the Magnificent Seven carried the index for months. But a narrow rally is fragile. If the one or two stocks doing the lifting stumble, there's nothing underneath to catch the fall.
Williams' "no clear signs" gives the market breathing room. But it doesn't give it a verdict. The NY Fed President is one of the most influential FOMC voters — a permanent member who runs the institution that executes Fed policy. When he pushes back on the hike narrative, the market listens. September hike odds likely eased from above 60% to somewhere near 50-50. But Warsh is still the Chair. And the 10-year yield still hit 4.81% — its highest since November 2023. Williams says the yield surge reflects a strong economy. The software stocks falling 8-18% despite beating earnings say it reflects something more uncomfortable: a repricing of what growth stocks are worth in a world where yields keep climbing.
Dell surged 13.7% and the S&P rose 0.46%, but nine of eleven sectors closed red, and the market is telling you the rally is a mask — two AI stocks carrying the cap-weighted index while the average stock continues to fall, because the 10-year yield at 4.81% is repricing every high-multiple growth stock in the market even as the companies behind those stocks beat their earnings estimates, and Friday's jobs report will determine whether Williams' "no clear signs" or Warsh's "discipline" wins the September debate. ADP at 38,000 leans toward Williams. If Friday's nonfarm payrolls confirm the softness — especially if the unemployment rate ticks up — the hike case weakens and the two-stock rally has a chance to broaden. If payrolls come in strong, Warsh's framework holds and the narrow rally stays narrow.
In early 2024, the S&P rallied 10% in the first quarter while breadth narrowed to seven mega-cap tech stocks. The equal-weight S&P underperformed the cap-weighted version by the widest margin in years. The rally was "real" by the index — and hollow by the components. It eventually broadened in the second and third quarters when the economy proved resilient. Today's question is the same: can Dell and Nvidia carry the index long enough for the rest of the market to catch up? Or does 4.81% on the 10-year break the narrow bridge first?
Three things I'm watching this week:
01 — Broadcom and Snowflake earnings tonight
Two reads on AI demand after Dell's blowout. Broadcom's custom AI chip business tells you whether the infrastructure boom extends beyond Nvidia and Dell. Snowflake's cloud data platform tells you whether enterprise AI workloads are accelerating. If both beat, the AI hardware rally broadens and tech has another leg. If either disappoints — especially Broadcom — the narrow rally narrows further.
02 — Friday's August jobs report: September 5
ADP's 38,000 is a weak lead-in. If nonfarm payrolls confirm the softness — consensus is around 150,000 — and the unemployment rate ticks above 4.0%, the hike case weakens substantially. Williams' "no clear signs" becomes the consensus view and the market rallies. If payrolls surprise strong — above 200,000 with wages at 4%+ — Warsh's "discipline" wins and September is a hike. Friday's number is the most important data point between now and the FOMC.
03 — Does the bond sell-off resume or stabilize?
The 10-year yield hit 4.81% — its highest since November 2023. It eased slightly after Williams' dovish comment. If yields stabilize here through Friday, the market can absorb the level. If yields push through 4.85% on a strong jobs report, the software repricing deepens and even the AI hardware names start feeling the gravity. The yield level is the floor under everything else.
Dell surged 13%. Nvidia rose 3.2%. The indexes snapped a three-day losing streak. Williams said "no clear signs" of a hike. The headline says relief. The internals say two stocks did all the work while nine sectors fell. The breadth is the truth. Friday's jobs report determines whether the truth changes.
That's it for today. See you tomorrow after the close.
— Tom Hartley
Today In Perspective · Published daily, Monday–Friday, after the close
This newsletter is for informational purposes only and does not constitute investment advice. The author is not a registered investment advisor. Past performance does not guarantee future results. Consult a qualified financial professional before making investment decisions.
